The Womble Bond Dickinson consumer warranty litigation team secured a victory for Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC (MBUSA) in Gould v. Los Angeles-M, Inc., et al. The Los Angeles County Superior Court granted summary judgment in MBUSA’s favor in its entirety, ending the case before trial. 

The plaintiffs claimed their new 2023 Mercedes-Benz G550 had a defect causing excessive oil consumption. Plaintiffs sought repurchase of the vehicle, civil penalties, and attorneys’ fees under California’s Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act,. The Court agreed with the defense, finding that MBUSA was entitled to judgment as a matter of law as to each of plaintiffs’ theories. 

Data over speculation. The team strategically relied on the vehicle’s service records and the manufacturer’s oil-consumption testing, both during ordinary course of repair and expert testing during the course of litigation. Based upon these tests, the Court found the oil consumption complaint “was a nonissue.” 

Dismantling Plaintiff’s expert. The Court agreed with defense  argument that the plaintiffs’ expert failed to confront the oil-consumption data with enough specificity. His opinion that the vehicle burned an “abnormal” amount of oil was too conclusory because he never identified a normal burn rate nor explained why the manufacturer’s acceptable range was inadequate. The Court also found his reliance on carbon buildup on a spark plug unpersuasive because he failed to explain how it showed an unacceptable level of oil consumption. 

Every theory rejected. The Court granted summary adjudication as to both the express and implied warranty theories. With no warranty violation, and with MBUSA reasonably believing the vehicle was not defective and conformed to warranty, the Court concluded there was no basis for civil penalties, effectively finding that MBUSA was entitled to judgment as a matter of law. 

The team’s well-planned defense strategy, including a second oil-consumption test during litigation, and close scrutiny of plaintiffs’ experts can defeat consumer litigation claims effectively and decisively before trial. Womble Bond Dickinson regularly defends automotive manufacturers and dealers in consumer warranty litigation. 

Miles Maurino, Chip White, and Harriet O’Malley were members of this litigation team, which is led by Mason Freeman, Macy M. Chan, and Ashley Kutz Kelley.

Read the summary judgment here.